OnPayvsSquare Payroll
Unbiased side-by-side comparison of verified reviews, user ratings, features, and pros/cons to help you decide which software fits your business needs.
Quick answer: OnPay vs Square Payroll
In our 2026 comparison of OnPay and Square Payroll, the products are too closely matched to name a clear overall winner. OnPay is rated 4.5/5 from 145 user reviews; Square Payroll is rated 4.5/5 from 137 user reviews.
Last updated
| At a glance | OnPay | Square Payroll |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Payroll Software | Payroll Software |
| User rating | 4.5/5 (145 reviews) | 4.5/5 (137 reviews) |
| Listed features | 11 | 12 |
| Integrations | 6 | 5 |
| Platforms | Windows, macOS, iOS, Android | Windows, macOS, iOS, Android |
| Ease of use | 4.5/5 | 4.5/5 |
| Customer support | 4.5/5 | 4.5/5 |
OnPay
Starting Price
Paid
Community Pulse
Advanced Ratings
Pros
- Flat, transparent pricing covering unlimited payroll runs, W-2 and 1099 processing, and tax filings across all 50 states.
- Robust features for businesses with complex payroll needs including multi-state operations, tipped employees, and piece-rate pay.
- Includes HR resources, employee self-service portal, and PTO tracking at no additional cost.
Cons
- User interface is functional but less polished and modern than competitors like Gusto.
- Smaller brand with fewer third-party integrations compared to larger platforms like QuickBooks or ADP.
- Benefits administration requires working with own brokers rather than in-house benefits marketplace.
Square Payroll
Starting Price
Paid
Community Pulse
Advanced Ratings
Pros
- Seamless integration with Square ecosystem, ideal for retail and restaurant businesses already using Square POS and payments .
- Simple, transparent pricing with no hidden fees; contractors can be paid for free (only W-2 employees incur fees).
- Handles new hire paperwork, quarterly payroll filings, and tax payments automatically, reducing administrative burden .
Cons
- Customer service is virtually impossible to reason with at times, unresponsive, and has caused chaos and distress for some businesses .
- Limited HR features compared to dedicated HR platforms; best for payroll-focused needs only.
- Best suited for Square ecosystem users; less optimal for businesses not using Square payments or POS.
Product Overview
What each platform does and who it's for
Primary Category
The main classification for each product
Editorial Quality Rating
Independent expert panel ratings and quality validations
OnPay
Expert Score
Square Payroll
Expert Score
Integration Ecosystem
Compare supported third-party apps and services
OnPay Integrations
Square Payroll Integrations
Platform Support
Supported platforms across each product
OnPay
Square Payroll
Sentiment & Feedback
Real-world pros and cons from verified users
OnPay Feedback
User sentiment analysis
- Flat, transparent pricing covering unlimited payroll runs, W-2 and 1099 processing, and tax filings across all 50 states.
- Robust features for businesses with complex payroll needs including multi-state operations, tipped employees, and piece-rate pay.
- Includes HR resources, employee self-service portal, and PTO tracking at no additional cost.
- No long-term contracts; month-to-month billing with easy cancellation and data export.
- User interface is functional but less polished and modern than competitors like Gusto.
- Smaller brand with fewer third-party integrations compared to larger platforms like QuickBooks or ADP.
- Benefits administration requires working with own brokers rather than in-house benefits marketplace.
Square Payroll Feedback
User sentiment analysis
- Seamless integration with Square ecosystem, ideal for retail and restaurant businesses already using Square POS and payments .
- Simple, transparent pricing with no hidden fees; contractors can be paid for free (only W-2 employees incur fees).
- Handles new hire paperwork, quarterly payroll filings, and tax payments automatically, reducing administrative burden .
- Staff can adjust time cards and submit requests if they forget to clock in/out, simplifying time tracking management
- Customer service is virtually impossible to reason with at times, unresponsive, and has caused chaos and distress for some businesses .
- Limited HR features compared to dedicated HR platforms; best for payroll-focused needs only.
- Best suited for Square ecosystem users; less optimal for businesses not using Square payments or POS.
Feature Comparison
Detailed side-by-side capability checklist
OnPay
11/14 features
- App Integrations
- Square integration
- Cross-device sync
- Security
- Team collaboration
- Time Tracking
- Direct deposit
- POS System
- Multi-platform support
- Benefits Administration
- Cloud payroll
- HR tools
- Payroll
- Reporting & Analytics
Square Payroll
11/14 features
- App Integrations
- Square integration
- Cross-device sync
- Security
- Team collaboration
- Time Tracking
- Direct deposit
- POS System
- Multi-platform support
- Benefits Administration
- Cloud payroll
- HR tools
- Payroll
- Reporting & Analytics
Login to see the complete feature comparison
Free account — takes 10 seconds
No credit card required. Create account
Pricing & Plans
Compare plans, features, and starting points side-by-side
OnPay Pricing
Custom configurations tailored to your organization.
Square Payroll Pricing
Custom configurations tailored to your organization.
Login to see detailed pricing plans & tiers
Free account — takes 10 seconds
No credit card required. Create account
Community Intelligence
Real-time crowdsourced comparison feedback and buyer signals.
Community Matchup Voting
Real-time crowdsourced buyer signals
Community vs. Editorial Alignment
Agreement between algorithmic rating & user voting
Draw
Calculated by features, pricing, support & ratings.
Awaiting Votes
Cast your vote above to update results.
Which software did you choose?
Share your decision anonymously with the community
Promote to OnPay vs Square Payroll Buyers
Capture high-intent Payroll Software evaluators
Head-to-Head Winner Analysis
Data-backed performance comparisons across pricing, features, usability, and support
Matchup Scoreboard
At-a-glance scorecard results
Weighted Overall Scorecard
Normalized composite performance scores
Smart Recommendation Matrix
Head-to-head decision matrix based on your business workflow
- Users wanting a streamlined, user-friendly workspace interface
- Teams looking for native integration with core workflow tools
- Buyers relying on extensive peer validation and battle-tested industry adoption
- Users wanting a streamlined, user-friendly workspace interface
- Teams looking for native integration with core workflow tools
- HR teams needing automated, compliant payroll processing with tax filing support
OnPay
Dimension scorecard
Multi-Dimension Performance
Winner Breakdown & Analysis
Tied for overall winner with a composite score of 90%.
Comparable pricing accessibility (Contact Vendor (No Free Trial)).
Tied with a solid set of 11 features.
Strong usability with a user rating of 4.5/5 stars.
Reliable support with a user rating of 4.5/5 stars.
Tied on platform availability (4 Platforms: Windows, macOS, iOS, Android).
Square Payroll
Dimension scorecard
Multi-Dimension Performance
Winner Breakdown & Analysis
Tied for overall winner with a composite score of 90%.
Comparable pricing accessibility (Contact Vendor (No Free Trial)).
Tied with a solid set of 12 features.
Strong usability with a user rating of 4.5/5 stars.
Reliable support with a user rating of 4.5/5 stars.
Tied on platform availability (4 Platforms: Windows, macOS, iOS, Android).
⚖️ Virtually Tied
OnPay and Square Payroll are virtually identical across all key dimensions. The right choice depends entirely on your team's specific workflow needs and integration requirements.
Composite Score Breakdown
Promote Your Software to Payroll Software Decision Makers
Frequently asked questions: OnPay vs Square Payroll
Which is better: OnPay or Square Payroll?
OnPay and Square Payroll are virtually identical across all key dimensions. The right choice depends entirely on your team's specific workflow needs and integration requirements. Neither product has a decisive overall lead, so the best choice depends on your workflow, budget and required integrations.
How do users rate OnPay and Square Payroll?
OnPay is rated 4.5/5 from 145 user reviews. Square Payroll is rated 4.5/5 from 137 user reviews. Ratings come from approved user reviews on SoftwareHope.
Which platforms do OnPay and Square Payroll support?
OnPay supports Windows, macOS, iOS and Android; Square Payroll supports Windows, macOS, iOS and Android.
Which is easier to use, OnPay or Square Payroll?
OnPay has an ease-of-use rating of 4.5/5, Square Payroll has an ease-of-use rating of 4.5/5. The difference is small, so both are similarly easy to adopt.
Most Helpful Reviews
Community-voted helpful feedback from verified users
Using OnPay saved our team significant time every week. Features run smoothly without lag or complicated setup steps.
Highly reliable software with excellent performance. An essential tool for professionals looking for efficiency and clean organization.
OnPay has been an outstanding addition to our daily workflow. The intuitive interface and fast processing speed make completing tasks effortless.
OnPay has been an outstanding addition to our daily workflow. The intuitive interface and fast processing speed make completing tasks effortless.
Login to read full user reviews
Free account — takes 10 seconds
No credit card required. Create account
Trending Software
Calculated via real engagement & conversions
Best Alternatives in Payroll Software
Other highly-rated software you might want to consider
